There are four ways to get your next car: lease a new one, buy new, buy used, or take over someone else's lease. None of them is always the best. The right one depends on how long you'll keep the car, how much you drive, how much cash you have up front, and whether you want a fixed end date.
The four options side by side
| Option | Cash up front | Commitment | Mileage limit | At the end |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Lease new | Drive-off: first payment, fees, often taxes | Usually 2-4 years | Yes | Return it or buy it |
| Buy new | Down payment, taxes, fees | Loan term, but you can sell any time | No | You own it |
| Buy used | Down payment, taxes, fees - on a lower price | Loan term, but you can sell any time | No | You own it |
| Take over a lease | Often little or none, plus the bank's transfer fee | Only the months left | Whatever's left in the allowance | Return it or buy it |
When leasing new makes sense
Leasing works best if you like a new car every few years, drive a predictable number of miles, and want the factory warranty the whole time you have the car. Monthly payments are usually lower than a loan on the same car, because you pay for the value the car loses during the lease, not the whole price.
The deal itself matters more than the brand. Brokers often beat the dealer down the street - see today's best lease deals (ranked by value) and cheapest lease deals (ranked by true monthly cost), and our guide to what makes a good lease deal.
When buying new makes sense
Buying new pays off when you plan to keep the car long after the loan is paid off, drive a lot of miles, or want to modify it. You carry the depreciation, but once the loan ends you have a car with no payment.
When buying used makes sense
New cars lose value fastest in their first few years, so a well-kept used car lets the first owner take that hit. It's usually the lowest total cost if you keep the car a long time - as long as you check its history and condition carefully (see the checklist below).
When taking over a lease makes sense
A lease takeover gives you a newer car with a short commitment and usually no down payment - you only take on the months that are left, and some sellers pay you a cash incentive to take it. It fits if you need a car for a year or two, or want to try a model before committing. Not every bank allows transfers, so check the rules for each brand and read how to take over a car lease.
Car shopping checklist
- Budget on total cost, not the monthly payment. A longer loan lowers the payment but raises what you pay overall.
- Get financing lined up before the dealer. A pre-approval from a bank or credit union gives you a rate to beat.
- Negotiate the price first, then financing, then your trade-in - one at a time.
- Check incentives. Manufacturers often offer low-APR financing or a cash rebate, and sometimes you have to choose one.
- Price insurance on the exact car before you sign.
- Decide on add-ons separately. Extended warranties and protection packages can wait until after you've agreed on the price.
- Read the contract and match every number to what you agreed.
How to compare used car listings
- Match year, trim, and miles. Compare like for like - a higher trim or lower miles can explain a higher price.
- Get a vehicle history report to check for accidents, title problems, and the number of owners.
- Ask for maintenance records.
- Check what's left of the factory warranty, or whether it's certified pre-owned.
- Pay for an independent inspection by a mechanic you choose before you buy.
- Compare the out-the-door price, including taxes and dealer fees.
Tips for first-time car buyers
- Know your credit score before you shop - it sets your rate on a loan or lease. See what credit score you need for a lease takeover.
- Keep the loan term reasonable. Stretching it out to lower the payment can leave you owing more than the car is worth.
- Don't skip the test drive - and drive it on roads you actually use.
- A short lease takeover can be a low-risk first car while you figure out what you like.
Financing a car? From our sister site AutoLoanRate.com
In-depth guides on auto loans and rates.
Common questions
Is it better to lease or buy a car?
Leasing usually means a lower monthly payment and a new car every few years, with mileage limits. Buying costs more each month but you own the car, with no mileage limits, and it usually costs less overall if you keep it a long time.
Is taking over a lease better than leasing new?
It can be: a shorter commitment, usually no down payment, and sometimes a cash incentive from the seller. Compare the effective monthly cost against today's cheapest new-lease deals to see which wins.
What should a first-time car buyer do first?
Check your credit, set a budget on the total cost, and get financing pre-approved before you visit a dealer.
Compare your options
Lease takeovers and broker lease deals, side by side - free to browse.
storefront Browse lease takeovers New lease deals