Best lease broker deals in New York
Every live deal from the lease brokers we track - not dealership ads - ranked by true effective cost: monthly payment, drive-off, and broker fee combined, as a percentage of MSRP. Lower is better. How scoring works
update Pricing last updated August 17, 2026.
Showing the 20 best lease deals available to New York drivers right now - nationwide brokers plus brokers serving New York. See the national board.
| Rank ▲ | Vehicle ⇅ | Score | True eff/mo ⇅ | % of MSRP | Monthly ⇅ | DAS | Term · Mi/yr | MSRP ⇅ | Broker | Area | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | 2026 Subaru Trailseeker Premium | C | $523 | 1.28% | $459 | $1,800 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $41,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #2 | 2026 Subaru Crosstek Premium AWD | C | $405 | 1.35% | $349 | $1,500 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $30,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #3 | 2026 Subaru Crosstek Base AWD | C | $395 | 1.36% | $339 | $1,500 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $29,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #4 | 2026 Subaru Ascent Touring | C | $738 | 1.39% | $669 | $2,000 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $53,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #5 | 2026 Subaru Outback Premium | D | $522 | 1.41% | $455 | $1,900 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $37,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #6 | 2026 Subaru Crosstek Wilderness AWD | D | $537 | 1.41% | $479 | $1,600 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $38,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #7 | 2026 Subaru Forester Premium AWD | D | $481 | 1.41% | $439 | $1,000 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $34,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #8 | 2026 Subaru Crosstek Limited AWD | D | $497 | 1.42% | $439 | $1,600 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $35,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #9 | 2026 Subaru Outback Touring XT | D | $706 | 1.44% | $639 | $1,900 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $49,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #10 | 2026 Subaru Outback Limited XT | D | $666 | 1.45% | $599 | $1,900 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $46,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #11 | 2026 Subaru Impreza Sport | D | $407 | 1.46% | $349 | $1,600 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $28,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #12 | 2026 Subaru Outbook Wilderness | D | $716 | 1.46% | $649 | $1,900 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $49,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #13 | 2026 Subaru Forester Sport AWD | D | $541 | 1.46% | $499 | $1,000 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $37,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #14 | 2026 Subaru Forester Limited AWD | D | $591 | 1.48% | $549 | $1,000 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $40,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #15 | 2026 Subaru Forester Standard AWD | D | $461 | 1.49% | $419 | $1,000 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $31,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #16 | 2026 Subaru Forester Wilderness AWD | D | $611 | 1.49% | $569 | $1,000 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $41,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #17 | 2026 Subaru WRX Base | D | $508 | 1.50% | $429 | $2,600 | 39 mo · 7.5k | $34,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #18 | 2026 Subaru Forester Touring AWD | D | $617 | 1.50% | $575 | $1,000 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $41,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #19 | 2026 Subaru Ascent Premium | D | $681 | 1.58% | $639 | $1,000 | 36 mo · 7.5k | $43,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
| #20 | 2026 Subaru WRX Limited | D | $640 | 1.60% | $599 | $1,100 | 39 mo · 7.5k | $40,000 | Autologicx $499 fee | NJ, NY | View ↗ |
Figures may or may not include sales tax and local/state fees, which vary by state — confirm an all-in quote with the broker before signing.
How the scores work
Lease communities benchmark deals with the "1% rule": a lease is solid when its real monthly cost is around 1% of the car's MSRP, and exceptional when it's meaningfully under that. The problem is that advertised payments hide the rest of the math - so we don't rank on the advertised number.
For every deal we compute the true effective monthly cost:
true eff/mo = monthly payment + (drive-off + broker fee) ÷ term
That number as a percentage of MSRP is the score:
- A+ - under 0.80% of MSRP per month. Exceptional; these go fast.
- A - 0.80–0.99%. Better than the 1% benchmark.
- B - 1.00–1.19%. A fair, market-rate lease.
- C - 1.20–1.39%. Below average - negotiate or keep looking.
- D - 1.40%+. You can almost certainly do better.
Payments are typically pre-tax and can vary by region, credit tier, and current manufacturer programs - always confirm the numbers with the broker. Deals without a published MSRP - or whose MSRP we estimated from a comparable listing - can't be scored fairly and aren't ranked here (they're still in the full list). Rankings update as brokers update their sheets.
Go deeper: What makes a good lease deal? The 1% rule explained · What is a car lease broker (and should you use one)?